Small Business Then and Now: Five Years of Shock, Strain, and Resilience

Highlights: 

• Small businesses demonstrated adaptability and resilience during the pandemic shock and the shift to sustained financial pressure from inflation and rising interest rates.

• Lenders must move beyond traditional metrics to use comprehensive data for nuanced segmentation, targeting, and proactive engagement to manage the uneven performance of SMBs in 2026.

When Market Pulse launched in 2020, small businesses were at the center of economic uncertainty. As the pandemic disrupted operations across industries, many small and medium-sized businesses (SMBs) faced an immediate and severe contraction. Five years later, the challenges look different, but the pressure has not disappeared. Rising costs, slower growth, and cautious consumers are shaping a new reality for Main Street.

Looking back at the last five years reveals not only how SMBs adapted but also how lenders can better support them in an increasingly complex environment.

In 2020, the outlook for small businesses was deeply uncertain. Delinquency rates among SMBs rose sharply, outpacing those seen in consumer credit. With widespread shutdowns and limited revenue, many businesses struggled to meet financial obligations, raising concerns about large-scale closures.

A key focus at the time was the role of government intervention, particularly the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP). While PPP provided critical short-term relief, uncertainty around loan forgiveness and the program’s eventual expiration created ongoing risk. Market Pulse discussions emphasized the fragility of small business finances and the uneven nature of recovery, often described as a “K-shaped” economy. 

At the same time, there were early signs of resilience. New business applications surged, signaling that even as some businesses closed, others were being created. This wave of entrepreneurial activity highlighted a key theme that would persist over the next five years: adaptability.

Despite historic disruption, SMBs demonstrated an ability to pivot quickly whether through digital adoption, new business models, or cost restructuring.

By mid-2023, the environment had shifted from immediate crisis to sustained financial pressure. Inflation, rising interest rates, and broader economic headwinds created a more challenging operating landscape for small businesses.

Market Pulse analysis and discussions during this period focused on the difficulty of assessing borrower health in a volatile environment. Traditional indicators were no longer sufficient on their own, as businesses faced uneven demand, rising input costs, and tighter margins. Lenders needed more dynamic, data-driven approaches to evaluate risk and identify viable opportunities.

For SMBs, the challenge was maintaining stability amid uncertainty. Access to capital became more complex, and financial performance varied widely across industries. Some businesses benefited from post-pandemic demand, while others struggled to regain footing.

This period marked a transition from broad-based support to targeted decisioning. The ability to differentiate between resilient and vulnerable businesses became critical for both lenders and the businesses themselves.

Today’s small business landscape is defined by slower economic momentum and continued cost pressures. Growth has moderated, with signs of consumer spending fatigue and softer GDP performance contributing to a more cautious outlook.

Operational costs, including labor, materials, and financing, remain elevated, putting pressure on margins. At the same time, job growth has slowed, adding another layer of complexity for SMBs trying to expand or even maintain current operations.

Yet despite these headwinds, small businesses are showing notable resilience. Many have adjusted to the higher-cost environment, adopting more disciplined financial strategies and focusing on efficiency. Market Pulse insights point to a more measured, steady state rather than sharp contraction, even as uncertainty remains.

This resilience is not without limits. The combination of slower growth and persistent costs means that risk remains elevated, and performance can shift quickly depending on broader economic conditions.

Looking across the past five years, one theme stands out: Supporting small businesses requires a more nuanced and proactive approach than ever before.

First, prioritize deeper visibility into business health. SMB performance is increasingly uneven, and surface-level metrics may not tell the full story. Leveraging more comprehensive data across credit behavior, cash flow, and industry trends can help lenders make more informed decisions.

Second, refine segmentation and targeting. Not all small businesses face the same risks or opportunities. Identifying which segments are demonstrating resilience, and which are under strain, can improve both risk management and growth outcomes.

Finally, strengthen relationships through proactive engagement. In a complex environment, SMBs value partners who provide clarity and guidance. Offering insights, flexible solutions, and timely communication can help build trust and long-term loyalty.

The past five years have tested small businesses in unprecedented ways. While the challenges have evolved, so has small businesses’ ability to adapt. By learning from this period of shock, strain, and resilience, lenders can better position themselves to support Main Street in whatever comes next.

Keep Your Business Goals Within Sight

Find our monthly Small Business Insights, National Consumer Credit Trends reports, the Market Pulse webinar and podcast, and more at our Market Pulse hub. 

Broaden your perspective with insights that inspire bold innovation, confident adaptation, and decisive leadership through our Trends and Insights resources.